cast(s): Brandon Flynn , Julia Goldani Telles , Ki Hong Lee , Annie Mumolo , Peter Scolari , Priscilla Lopez , Susan James Berger , Monique Kim , Lindsay Mushett , Tom Proctor , Mick O'Rourke , Jude Washock , Tiffany Milian , Natalie Paige Goldberg , Anthony Traina , Diana Ruppe , Jon Peterson , Danny Reuben , Tim Simon , Rhaechyl Walker , Sea McHale , Kendra Kirby , Alexander Low , Lucia Giannetta , Shari Abdul , Natalie Paige Goldberg , Sarah Litzsinger , Michael Callahan , Liz Cameron , James A. Pierce III , Mary Scarpello ,